PCB Failure Analysis (simple)




Mohammad Furqan Malaysia


OpenFeb 26, 2019
I have bought a SFA (France) make Lifting Station Model Sanicubic 2 Classic (1W+1S) -1500 Watts (Single Phase) sewage pump recently from an authorized dealer in New Delhi, India for use in a small office.

The PCB burnt out within 1 month due to what I believe was a broken Neutral line into our commercial building at the pole (electricity company's fault). This type of problem is routine in India, as are voltage fluctuations and constant power cuts (at least 2-20 times a day depending). The power company, practically speaking, will never reimburse for damages like this. All white-goods appliances companies market their products in India as 'made for India' which don't require external voltage stabilizers anymore.

The pump is made and sold by a French company who touts a 5 year warranty, best in the world, etc., but they say it's not their problem. The pump cost me $2,400USD and the replacement PCB about $200-400. It's not so much they money as the principle. None of our Indian-made pumps or equipment had any problems. I bought the French one because it's a sealed unit and supposedly better.

As far as I can tell, only one component burnt out, which is the little blue (resistor?) at the corner of the board. I believe SFA should have engineered some kind of intrinsic protection into the PCB like a fuse, since a Neutral break and voltage fluctuations happen every day in India.

Could you take a look and give me your opinion on the cause and whether or not I have a point? I can send better photos.

Skills & Expertise Required

Circuit Design Electrical Engineering PCB Design 

Offer to work on this project closes in 123 days!

Submit A Proposal

Share this project with your friends

Freelancers You May Hire

Here are our top professional picks for you to hire

Similar Projects

I need someone to convert these Eur...

I need someone to convert these European electrical specs to American specs for a customer in the U.S who will be using the specs to install the electrical components. Must be a licensed engineer

Hourly, $15.00

Electronics power control component...

I will need someone highly conversant in electronics power control and the characteristics and calculations associated with electronic power control components such as diacs, triacs, PUTs, GTOs, etc....read more

Fixed, $30.00

Coding for Solar PV System

I would like to accompany a Solar PV system with some code. I am aware that as this is the first step in communication throughout the design process, it will be unlikely to get the system to actually...read more

Fixed, $50.00

DC electrical assistance for submar...

Its a tested speedboat/submarine concept vessel. I need to add to team in order to return to water for subsea hover thrust tests. Initially, only a small amount of help will be needed. For example,...read more

Hourly, $18.00

Rapid prototyping for electronic ed...

Looking for a freelancer to help with a rapid prototyping process for an educational electronic game. Preferably, we would like someone who can create a schema, design a pcb board, assemble the compon...read more

Hourly, $32.00